Overview
The Hamlet at Olde Oyster Bay is a 24-hour guard-gated, resort-style community of about 141 homes in Plainview, built in 2001. Its strength is fitting several budgets and lifestyles in one place — from carriage-house condos to single-family homes — with an on-site lake, restaurant, indoor and outdoor pools, and a spa, plus a quick Main Line commute from nearby Hicksville.
Highlights
Guard-gated + resort amenities
A 24-hour manned gatehouse; a clubhouse/ballroom, indoor and outdoor pools, a spa and fitness center, sauna and steam, lighted tennis, pickleball, a half basketball court, a putting green, plus a lake with a boardwalk and boating and a waterfront restaurant, with concierge and valet service.
Home types across budgets
About 141 homes — detached single-family, lake-view villas, and upper/ground-level carriage-house condos — giving options from entry to step-up, roughly $875K to $1.4M.
Fast Main Line commute via Hicksville
About 3.4 miles / a 6-minute drive to the Hicksville station; Hicksville is on the LIRR Main Line, roughly 41–55 minutes to Penn — one of the more efficient commutes on Long Island.
The real monthly number, stated
HOA common charges run about $540–$755/month by home, plus a separate mandatory dining fee of about $165/month — fold that into your true carrying cost. We confirm the exact figures on the unit you choose.
Best for
Best for a buyer who wants a full-amenity, guard-gated community with home types across budgets and a faster Main Line commute.
- Nearest LIRR
- Hicksville · Main Line / Port Jefferson Branch
- To Manhattan
- ~41–55 min to Penn Station
- By car
- Hicksville LIRR station ~3.4 mi / ~6 min from Plainview
Location & Commute
The community is in Plainview, Nassau County (Central Nassau). The nearest LIRR station is Hicksville (Main Line / Port Jefferson Branch), about 3.4 miles / a 6-minute drive, roughly 41–55 minutes to Penn.
Community details (home counts, HOA dues, pricing, amenities) change over time, and HOA dues vary by unit and floor plan; Homix re-verifies by unit before touring or writing an offer.
Sources: thehamletoysterbay.com · longislandhomesandcondos.com · activerain.com · condoli.com · real-estate.longislandluxuryhomes.com · laffey.com
Homix
Want to see this community?
Share this page with a client, or contact Homix to tour, verify HOA dues, and see what's available.