Overview
Stone Hill at Muttontown is a double-gated, 24-hour guard-manned private community on Long Island's North Shore — just 80 custom single-family estate homes spread across roughly 148 acres, each on a 1 to 2.5+ acre lot. Its single biggest draw: genuine round-the-clock security paired with true North Shore estate living, about 35 minutes by car from Manhattan.
Highlights
Double-gated, manned 24/7
The entrance is double-gated with a 24-hour staffed gatehouse and a video camera surveillance system. For buyers who weigh security and privacy, that's a real, everyday layer of protection.
Custom single-family estates on large lots
Just 80 custom single-family estate homes, each on a 1 to 2.5+ acre lot. There's room for a private pool, tennis court, or even a horse barn on your own land.
Clubhouse and full amenity set
A private clubhouse with a gathering and card room, a heated indoor pool, a private tennis facility, plus a fitness center and locker rooms. There's also an equestrian trail and deed-restricted open space.
HOA handles the outside upkeep
The HOA covers landscaping for individual lots and driveway snow removal, and maintains the community's common areas. Less day-to-day upkeep, more time to enjoy the estate.
Best for
Best for a buyer who wants a custom single-family estate on a large lot and puts guard-gated, 24-hour private security at the top of the list.
- Nearest LIRR
- Syosset · Port Jefferson Branch
- By car
- Village of Muttontown on Long Island's North Shore
Location & Commute
The community sits in the incorporated Village of Muttontown, within the Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County, on Long Island's North Shore — on the historic former B.K. Stevens estate. For commuting, the official site cites about 35 minutes by car east to Manhattan; the nearest LIRR station is Syosset on the Port Jefferson Branch.
Community details (home counts, HOA dues, pricing, amenities) change over time, and HOA dues vary by unit and floor plan; Homix re-verifies by unit before touring or writing an offer.
Sources: stonehillatmuttontown.com · stonehillhoa.net · newhomesource.com · muttontownny.gov · en.wikipedia.org
Homix
Want to see this community?
Share this page with a client, or contact Homix to tour, verify HOA dues, and see what's available.