Skip to content
← All areas

Market report · October 2026

Shelter Island housing market report

Suffolk County · Data as of November 8, 2026 · Based on OneKey® MLS · Updated monthly

12-month median price about flat; inventory up 16.0%; buyer's market

Market temperature · months of supply

Seller's <4Buyer's >6

21.8 months · buyer's market

Median sale price

—

Last year $1.84M

Closed sales

0

Last year 3 · −100.0%

Homes for sale

29

Last year 25 · +16.0%

Avg. days on market

—

Last year 140 days

% of original list

—

Last year 91.6%

New listings

4

Last year 2 · +100.0%

Month and last 12 months

MetricOctober 2025October 2026ChangeThru 10/2025Thru 10/2026Change
New listings24+100.0%40400.0%
Closed sales30−100.0%2016−20.0%
Avg. days on market140——142221+55.6%
Median sale price$1,845,000——$1,810,000$1,812,500+0.1%
% of original list91.6%——87.2%83.6%−4.1%
Homes for sale / Avg. homes for sale2529+16.0%2825−10.7%
Median sale price (rolling 12 months)
—$500K$1M$1.5M$2M$2.5M2014201620182020202220242026

From 2013-01 to 2026-10, the rolling 12-month median moved from $551K to $1.81M.

Highlights

  • 10-year median +109.5%
  • 0% sold above original list in 12 months

For sale today

Shelter Island Single-family 24 homes

View listings →

Curious what your home is worth?

Source: OneKey® MLS, calculated by Homix following OneKey's market report method; figures may differ slightly from OneKey's own reports. Prices do not account for concessions or down-payment assistance; small samples can make percent changes look extreme.